Menu Close
Advanced Search
Forum Scope






Start typing a member's name above and it will auto-complete

Match



Options



Minimum search word length is 3 characters - maximum search word length is 84 characters
Avatar
Forum Menu
The forums are currently locked and only available for read only access
Late fruit with more seeds?
1
November 14, 2019 - 11:00 am
Post Actions
Avatar
John S

PDX OR

Posts: 3082

I have been eating my American persimmons and noticing that the last fruits tend to have a lot more seeds that the earlier fruits.  I wonder if this is generally true among other persimmons or other fruit.

In some ways, it makes sense.  The tree might want to hold onto the fruit with seeds a little longer to make sure that the seeds are fully mature. That's the whole point of making the fruit. The seedless fruit doesn't have this same need, because there are no seeds to mature.

Whaddya think?

John S
PDX OR

2
November 14, 2019 - 6:39 pm
Post Actions
Avatar
Rooney

Vancouver SW Washington

Posts: 880

It also applies to the apples and pears that I have seen codling moth damage on. Every year my favorite summer japanese/asian pear set two crops. The first 5-10% of the crop is seen turning yellow and sweeter then the green ones at the last of July due to no seeds and vacant larvae. The next 90% come on another 10 days later than the first. So both the moth larvae and I (with my extended summer harvest) get what each of us bargained for. 

I don't understand the way it is why my first crop gets so sweet. There are always so many curious things and unanswered questions about fruit we don't know for sure.

3
November 18, 2019 - 7:37 pm
Post Actions
Avatar
John S

PDX OR

Posts: 3082

Come to think of it, I have seen many fruits with codling moth drop early.  Obviously, the seeds aren't viable, as the codling moth feeds on it.  It makes sense for the tree to stop investing in it, and perhaps leave it on the ground for the earliest, hungriest animals to munch completely first, saving the seeds for partial munching on mature fruit later.
John S
PDX OR

4
November 30, 2019 - 5:10 pm
Post Actions
Avatar
buzzoff


Posts: 84

Hnuh?

An apple under Codling Moth attack, tries it's best to ripen, before insects completely destroy it.

Thus it ripens very early, and falls.  Thereafter, it quickly rots.

For many years, my Ashmead's Kernel, apple tree was largely bare by September.

Every piece of fruit was badly damaged by worms. 

This year, due to improved orchard clean-up, some apples were not attacked.

Still hanging on the tree, in fact.

5
December 2, 2019 - 8:53 pm
Post Actions
Avatar
John S

PDX OR

Posts: 3082

As far as I know, we're just hypothesizing.  If the apple is attacked before the seed can mature in the fruit,  it makes sense for the tree to quit investing in it.

John S
PDX OR