Many years ago, with complete ignorance, a cherry pit was planted. The resulting seedling was re-planted in a spot which is probably not ideal for sweet cherries. Now there is a small, attractive, healthy tree of roughly 10 ft height, at least a decade old, which is entirely unproductive, and given its origin and location, may never be productive.
It would be nice to plant something productive there, but I am not comfortable with killing a healthy tree. Any ideas for finding this tree a new home?
Seems like it would be possible, given its age, to stump it off belly high, then bark graft it over to a variety you approve of.
I have done this for people before, but you would need to come up with the exact scion wood, since I have no idea what you want in a cherry tree.
After this procedure, it would be about 6 or 7 years before you could not really tell that somebody took a chainsaw and stumped your tree off! I have apples I have done this with and, except for the change in bark characteristics, you cannot tell that it was ever chain-saw-stumped!
You are proposing to dig it out for give away?? That would be a big job -- and cherry rootstocks are a couple bucks apiece. Better to make use of all the live roots that already exist in your ground. 
Sometimes the effort and horsepower going into 'saving' a tree, far exceed the merits of the plant. Do not feel bad to get rid of it. From what you've said, I cannot see any redeeming purpose for the tree. A dwarf Cherry is far more manageable and will bear fruit a lot quicker than if you topwork a seedling.
If you read the works of guys like TV Munson and Luther Burbank, you will find that being a bit mercernary and willing to get rid of mediocre plants is the only way to go, unless you want to have a yard filled with worry and care.
I think most of us gardeners hate to take a plant out, but space is the usual limiting quantity, and that tree takes up valuable space.
quokka,
I agree with the suggestions above. Regarding the ‘stumping’ and bark-grafting; I’d hack off it’s branches a foot or two beyond the trunk, allow it to send up suckers, then do whip & tongue grafts to those the following dormant season. Topworking, or anything near as brutal on cherry trees that age has a low percentage of success; and half a tree’s hardly better than what you’ve got...
The second suggestion is what I did with two (magnificent) cherry trees I’d simply tried to graft pollinators to at that age. While learning the advice above… I attempted a series of cleft grafts, none took. The trees were sadly removed – but quickly replaced by two Desert King figs, donated by a friend.
...so I’d recommend the second option. I know it’s tuff for Orchardist’s to cull what often feels like their offspring… Just assemble your tools, cut it to a 5 foot stump (for leverage) and start digging. It quickly becomes work … but as that hole appears ... your mind instantly begins pondering the possibilities 
" title="Wink" />
I'd agree about the many uses for fruit wood....for smoking! I've found homes for apple, cherry, plum & pear from our collection of massive burn piles before I torched them a few months ago - people wanted them for smoking uses; in fact have a guy begging for apple & cherry prunings right now!
And having taken out many seedling fruit trees in the last year, it's hard to feel all that bad about giving space to trees that either don't produce fruit or only inferior fruit - takes just as much care to get bad fruit as it does good fruit!
Dave
Idyllwild
simplepress
jafar
Marsha H
Viron
1 Guest(s)