Hi Brian,

Welcome to HOS. I am fairly new myself. I was interested in what you mean by 3 year old 5 variety tree. Do you mean one tree that has 5 different varieties of apples on it? If so, what varieties? Apples need a pollinator so you need 2 varieties in bloom at the same time. I am assuming whoever grafted the tree grafted pollinating varieties. Did any 2 varieties bloom at the same time? Was the tree bought locally? I am not sure but I think some apples require some cool weather to produce. Perhaps you are not getting enough cold temps. I wouldn't give up on a tree after 3 years but if it blooms and there are bees for pollination and a pollinating variety, you should get apples. Ok, I will let the experts answer now. This is just some of my thoughts.

I'm going to lock this topic, so all further discussion can occur in this thread:

viewtopic.php?t=575