
I think columnar apples are more of a novelty than anything else (except extreme space constraint) - they have no real advantages for taste, productivity, or disease resistance. So if it is mainly novelty you are after it will probably work fine but for any of these other reasons I would suggest just grafting one really great apple onto the rootstock that suits you...the world is not short on really great apple varieties !

Mostly I agree with Eric. THere are a few urban neighborhoods where a columnar apple could fit better. They cost twice as much and produce 1/5 as much as a semi-dwarf, but I live in the suburbs and I can grow trees. WE live in the suburbs so we can grow a real garden.
John S
PDX OR

Hey Jimmbo, a fruiting trunk … with production above as well… Interesting Though keep in mind, as the top grows it shades out the trunk, so the shaded fruit may not ‘color up’ well, or continue to form at all. But I can’t think of any harm in trying…
I prune 3 or 4 ‘columnar apple trees’ for friends, and agree, they’re nothing special. But, they are hardy … and definitely consistent in their desire to grow straight up - and not out And, they’re covered with fruit spurs.
I, too, have had space, thus no reason to restrict the width of a tree. But, in a tight setting (with adequate sun..), columnar’s have likely earned a place. As far as using them as an interstim, from the vigor I’ve witnessed, they’d likely do fine in passing nutrients to whatever’s above, while producing along ‘the trunk’ for awhile at least.
If you try it - please keep us posted.
...one consideration may be any current plant patents on a specific columnar variety. Not an attorney, I can’t give advice, so proceed at your discretion.

The gene for columnar is dominant so if you planted seeds from columnar trees, roughly half of them would express that trait, plus or minus. Depending on your needs, super-early apple pollen or extra late ripening types may make very interesting crosses.
Gold Rush is quite late, not sure about its track record of throwing superior offspring, though.
Idyllwild
simplepress
jafar
Marsha H
Viron
1 Guest(s)